Seasonal Favorites
Fondant Bat Cookie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Fondant Bat Cookie
$3.25
Fondant Ghost Cookie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Fondant Ghost Cookie
$4.50
Fondant Jack-O-Lantern Cookie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Fondant Jack-O-Lantern Cookie
$4.50
Ghost Cupcake
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Ghost Cupcake
$3.95
Jack-O-Lantern Cupcake
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Jack-O-Lantern Cupcake
$3.95
Spider Cupcake
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Spider Cupcake
$3.95
Fondant Pumpkin Cookie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Fondant Pumpkin Cookie
$4.50
9" Pumpkin Pie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
9" Pumpkin Pie
$18.50
9" Sweet Potato Pie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
9" Sweet Potato Pie
$18.50

Coming November 01, 2026

9" Whipped Cream Pumpkin Pie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
9" Whipped Cream Pumpkin Pie
$25.95
Caramel Apple Layer
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Caramel Apple Layer
From $34.00
Choose options
Fall Cookie Decorating Kit
Fall Cookie Decorating Kit
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Fall Cookie Decorating Kit
$38.00
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Cheesecake
From $17.50
Choose options
Pumpkin Cheesecake Slice
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Cheesecake Slice
$4.50
Pumpkin Scone
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Scone
$3.25
Pumpkin Spice Muffins - 6 pack
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Spice Muffins - 6 pack
$8.95
Pumpkin Spice Ring
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Spice Ring
$15.95
Pumpkin Spiced Latte Cupcake
Pumpkin Spiced Latte Cupcake
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Spiced Latte Cupcake
$3.75
Pumpkin Spiced Roll
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Spiced Roll
$14.95
Pumpkin Spiced Roll Slice
Pumpkin Spiced Roll Slice
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Spiced Roll Slice
$5.50
Pumpkin Sugar Cookie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Pumpkin Sugar Cookie
$3.75
Mincemeat Pie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
Mincemeat Pie
$21.95

Coming November 01, 2026

9" Bourbon Pecan Pie
Apple Annie's Bake Shop
9" Bourbon Pecan Pie
$25.95

Coming November 12, 2026